**Decisions, decisions (and Promises, promises)
Kid 1: When I grow up, I’m going to marry Tracey Downs.
Kid 1: When I grow up, I’m going to marry Tracey Downs.
Kid
2: Bet you don’t.
Kid 1: Why?
Kid 2: She’s
marrying me. Nuh nuh-nuh NUH nuh.
Kid 1: You’re, like, so childish.
Students need to know
Kid 1: You’re, like, so childish.
Statement of Form
Future with going to: subject + am/is/are + going to +
base form
Future simple: subject + will (or might) + base form
With ‘probably’:
(positive) will probably
(negative) probably won’t
Native speakers
have many different ways of referring to the future (there is no ‘future tense’) and if you ask
them to say why they used a particular form, they will have no idea. This is a fairly reliable summary:
If you’re talking
about a plan, use “going to”.
If, on the other
hand, it’s something you’ve just , now,
decided, (including making an offer,
promise or threat) use “will”.
You might be making
a prediction, in which case it
depends whether you just ‘feel’ it in
your bones (“will”), or you have ‘evidence’ to support the
prediction (“going to”).
Unfortunately, students in practice rarely know,
or have time to work out, if they've got evidence or not.
“Will” and “going
to” both indicate certainty, so
if you’re not so sure, you need “might”, or “probably”.
For something seen as "fixed" in the future, like a timetabled event, we can use the present simple.
For something seen as "fixed" in the future, like a timetabled event, we can use the present simple.
“Will” also pops up a lot in:
promises…
♬ And you'll never walk alone,
You'll N-E-V-E-R walk...♬
(Ok, we get it.)
♬ And you'll never walk alone,
You'll N-E-V-E-R walk...♬
(Ok, we get it.)
Friendly stranger: “I’ll
help you with those heavy bags, Madam.”
… threats…
Paranoid tourist: “Go
away, or I’ll call the Police.”
… and refusals.
Friendly stranger: “She
won’t let me help her, the ungrateful, toffee-nosed...”
[Err, that’s enough,
let’s have the movie quote:]
Withnail: "I'll show the lot of you! I'm gonna be a star!"
Withnail: "I'll show the lot of you! I'm gonna be a star!"
Students struggle with
Which form to use, as they
are often essentially the same. As we’ve seen, all three, in their basic forms can express certainty. "Going to" and
"Present continuous" can both be used for plans. "Will" and
"going to” both make predictions. Notice how these two forms are often
used interchangeably on the weather forecast:
"And now the climate
change weather: They'll suffer from the sun in Siberia. It's going to positively pour down in Persia,
and it’ll be fairly foggy in France. Britain – start checking your insurance."
The student’s
strategy for straightening out the confusion is just to use “will” for any
reference to the future. After all, they believe, it IS the future, isn’t it?
It can be, but it often isn’t. As a result, the most common error is for
students to overuse “will”.
Presentation idea
Climate change weather
forecast (predictions)
It is widely
understood that climate change will mean unexpected weather in many locations.
Establish this with the students. Optionally,
get a world map – write above it whatever day tomorrow will be. So if your
lesson is on a Wednesday, put Thursday. Place (or draw) on it some obvious
symbols for the weather – rain, cloud, hot weather, snow perhaps. Pre-prepare
some sentences about the weather, cut into two pieces:
“It will be hot in Murmansk.”
“You’re going to have snow in the Sahara.”
“Scotland will see temperatures of
35 to 40 degrees.”
“They isn’t going to be much rain in Manchester.”
SS are given these
mixed up. Referring to your map, they have to match the two pieces to make
accurate sentences. You then have several examples from which to highlight that
we can use either the “will” or “going to” structure to express a prediction.
Elicit from students a few more examples of likely bizarre conditions if global
warming takes hold.
Fun practice
Don’t spoil it!
(Present simple for the “unchangeable future”)
Establish with the
class that few things are more annoying than someone spoiling a movie by
telling you what is going to happen. Select two short, interesting video clips
for the class to watch. They should be easy to follow with the sound turned
off. If they are genuinely funny, this is ideal. Get half the students to turn
away (or go out of the room for a time). The other half watch and enjoy the
clip. Then swap around with the second clip. Now pair up a student from each
group and have everyone watch each clip. The idea is that those who have seen
it “spoil” it for the student watching it for the first time by stating what is
just about to happen:
E.g. He falls over. She hits him. The police arrive,
but they’re too late.
Optionally, get the
listener in each pair to react angrily:
Don’t spoil it!
I’ve got a secret. (Arrangements) Tell the class that they will be asking
questions to guess what someone’s arrangements are for that weekend. Select two
of the strongest students to go out of the room. Tell the class they have gone
out of the room to concoct a fictitious set of arrangements. When they return,
the class will have twenty Yes / No questions with which to find out all of the
following:
What the
arrangement is, where, what time, who with, planned mode of transport.
Then go and talk to
the two students outside the room, making sure you cannot be heard by those in
the room. THERE ARE NO ARRANGEMENTS. Instead, when the pair go back into the
room, they simply answer “Yes” if the question ended in a vowel, and “No”, if
it ended in a consonant! (Note, having two students answering means they can
confer in a whisper if need be – seemingly checking their story, but in reality
checking their spelling!)
E.g:
Q1: “Are you going
to a party?”
“No, we aren’t.”
Q2: “Are you meeting
some friends?”
“No, we aren’t.”
Q3: “Are you going
to the cinema?”
“Yes, we are!”
Q4 “Are you meeting
at lunchtime?”
“Yes, we are!”
Q5: “Are you going
by train?”
“No, we aren’t.”
Q6: “Are you going
by bicycle?”
“Yes, we are!”
And so on. Stop the
activity when you reach twenty questions asked, or the five “facts” have been
discovered. Get the inquisitors to summarise the plans. You can then reveal
what was really going on – and prepare to take some derision. Wait until you
have a completely fresh class to try it again, or next time, let the students
going outside decide fresh criteria (e.g. Answer “Yes” if the question has more
than seven words; if it uses the letters “k” or “j”…)
No comments:
Post a Comment